Rob Corddry

Jack

Leslie Bibb

Vanessa

Keegan-Michael Key

F'resnel

Paul Scheer

Ron

Rob Huebel

Mickey

Thomas Lennon

Father Padrigo

Michael Ian Black

Dr. Marshall

Brittney Alger

Italian Nurse

Dave Holmes

Rental Car Guy

Alex Berg

Mrs. Nussbaum / Cheerful Guy

Riki Lindhome

Marjorie

David Pasquesi

Cardinal Vicente

David Wain

Dr. Marsden

Kumail Nanjiani

Cable Guy

Robert Ben Garant

Father Sebastian

Cathy Shim

Catholic School Girl

Jenny Robertson

Mail Carrier